Justice Minister Sean Fraser informed a committee of MPs on Thursday that the Liberal government will retain the advance directives within its proposed bill that amends the medically assisted dying legislation, preventing MPs from voting on these elements separately.
Fraser stated, “We have a chance to alleviate suffering, which is just as crucial, if not more so, than adhering to legislative timelines.”
Conservative members of the justice committee challenged the minister to clarify why Bill C-41, aimed at updating medical assistance in dying (MAID) laws, is being expedited in Parliament without permitting separate votes on its two main amendments. This bill was presented in the House of Commons on October 27.
One amendment prohibits individuals from receiving medically assisted dying solely based on mental illness, while the other permits individuals with declining mental capacity to request MAID in advance.
“Why are you not separating the bill? Why are you compelling parliamentarians to address a complex issue on a timeline that doesn’t need to exist for advance requests?” Conservative MP Andrew Lawton queried Fraser.
The MAID legislation was first enacted by the government in 2016. However, the Superior Court of Quebec invalidated the law in 2019, as it was restricted to cases where death was “reasonably foreseeable.”
Bill C-7, which received parliamentary approval in March 2021, eliminated that restriction in accordance with the court’s decision while temporarily delaying the extension of MAID to situations involving only mental illness until March 2023.
The provision concerning mental health was subsequently postponed to 2024 and then again to March 2027. Consequently, unless Bill C-41 is enacted or the government delays the date further, MAID will automatically broaden to encompass mental illness by March of next year.
Fraser emphasizes preventing suffering
The amendment permitting individuals to give advance consent when their condition will eventually impair their ability to make that choice is not affected by any legislative timeline.
Fraser explained, “While a legislated timeline exists concerning mental illness, I don’t intend to imply that the issue of advance requests isn’t also urgent,” justifying his choice to keep both amendments within the same bill.
The minister conveyed to MPs that the choice to retain both amendments in a single bill was not based on medical counsel, but rather on his apprehension that further delaying advance requests could result in unnecessary suffering.
-
Ottawa to indefinitely extend MAID exclusion for people solely suffering from mental illness
-
Government to reveal next steps for medically assisted dying, justice minister says
“My motivation to address this matter promptly arises from discussions I’ve had with individuals enduring suffering,” Fraser remarked.
“It is incredibly distressing to converse with someone who understands their life is nearing its end and faces the additional challenge of potentially losing their decision-making capacity.”
Adequate safeguards assured
Fraser stated that the topic has been thoroughly examined, and as long as appropriate safeguards are established to ensure the effective management of advance requests, the legislation should advance quickly.
He mentioned that Bill C-41 is secure, as a physician specializing in the patient’s illness is required to approve the conditions under which MAID can be applied.
Fraser noted that two independent medical assessors must then evaluate the situation to ascertain that the approved conditions have been satisfied, while also confirming that the individual’s suffering is intolerable and the illness is irreparable.
“That is when the individual would qualify for medical assistance in dying under the proposed framework,” he explained.
Fraser emphasized that individuals who may no longer recognize themselves or others but seem content and enjoying life would not qualify, as they are not experiencing intolerable suffering.
Tag: rewrite-pending

